A Summer Place by Percy Faith. Funny, I thought it would be "Donna" as that is my name and when I was in school there were 4 other Donna's in the same class. I thought our parents could be a little more original. Oh well!!
OK, had to look it up. Donna by Ritchie Valens in 1959. I was born 1960. Mona Lisa was another song that was popular in 1959. I wonder if it was a toss up?